01
Category Research
We start every review by mapping the full competitive landscape. We identify all major products in a category, read manufacturer specs, and study real-world user feedback across Amazon, Reddit, and enthusiast forums. This ensures we're comparing the right products against each other.
02
Expert Source Aggregation
We compile and synthesize reviews from trusted expert sources — RTINGS, Wirecutter, Tom's Guide, What Hi-Fi, and category specialists. We look for consensus across sources rather than relying on any single opinion. If experts disagree, we flag it.
03
Real User Validation
Expert labs don't always catch long-term reliability issues, build quality problems, or software quirks. We cross-reference with thousands of verified Amazon and retailer reviews to surface common complaints and repeated praise that appear across a large sample of real owners.
04
Value Assessment
A product's score is never purely about raw performance — it has to be appropriate for its price. We score products relative to what you pay. A $50 product that punches above its weight can outscore a $300 product that underdelivers at its price point.
05
Editorial Scoring
Our final score is a weighted composite across the criteria below. We update scores when products receive significant firmware updates, when new competitors enter the market, or when long-term reliability data changes our assessment.
Scoring Criteria
Performance30%
Value for Money25%
Build Quality & Durability20%
Features & Usability15%
Long-Term Reliability10%
Have a question about how we scored a specific product? Contact us — we're happy to walk through our reasoning.